Friday, March 24, 2006
Moral Economy
I’m not the first to point out that progressives who are organizationally divided, compartmentalized by whatever issue they want to advocate, need to all gather activist strength to promote each others’ issues, even if it means overlooking peripheral disagreements with other progressive groups if it’s for progress on an issue most of us hold dear. As a hypothetical example, working women advocating equal pay to men or guaranteed maternity leave should be able to count on support from those advocating economic justice for the marginalized working class, and the women’s groups in turn support the marginalized worker, even if some members of the two groups may disagree as to whether hiring preferences should prioritize females or the historically underrepresented ethnicities.
While I want to focus on the moral economy, the flux which is the current status of our main local paper, the Mercury, highlights the increasingly vital role publications like De-Bug occupy as an informational source. Depending on the Mercury’s future owner, news quality and local coverage in particular could descend abysmally. Alternative news sources, which nationally have become essential to get what’s really going on, may become much more essential than mainstream news to figure what what’s really happening locally. Political and economic actors (in other words, people) can only be as educated in their actions as the sources of information, one of which is the media. Strengthening the web of local media in every way is key.
While our existence is much more than this, it is partly founded on the democratic (or dictatorial) nature of politics, media, and the economy. To that effect, I propose a set of reforms all progressive should back and use to inform any future debate on these issues. These reforms are a building block for others to contribute more ideas for bettering the existence of the vast majority of people in our local spheres and ultimately everywhere.
1. Promote multi-producer trading affiliations with barter-based exchange.
When people can get close to the same thing from someone in their community with the skill to provide that good or service, by all means figure out an adequate trade and save your money rather than depositing green into a consumer-creating machine with a distant profit center. Now if you’re sure the business is locally owned then it may be other story, but you still may want to consider the non-cash trade rather than a purchase.
2. Social enterprises are worker-owned, usually in the service- or capital-light industries. Depending on the people involved, the possibilities could be a restaurant or coffee shop, office or hotel cleaning service, clothes or soap-making, or something totally different which could be pursued, and programs to provide money, loans, or tax breaks to these organizations should be advocated.
3. CA Proposition 13 should exclude firms. Giving away all that lost property tax revenue to firms is not in keeping with the save the old people arguments for the proposition, and the argument business would leave is not strong since California offers all sorts of benefits that no other state has, and many qualities that are totally unmatched in the Western U.S. The concentration of existing businesses, the coast, Silicon Valley, Hollywood, the Universities all offer competitive advantages businesses will not ignore if they are forced to pay their share of property tax. The revenue should go into improving all levels of public education. This is the historically, though eroded of late, use of property tax revenue.
4. Revoke CA Proposition 64 to enable preemptive suits against harmful corporate output such as chemicals or pollution. To get rid of CA proposition 64 opens the door for watchdog groups to use the courts to stop firms from producing in ways that will likely damage humans or the environment. Yes, shockingly, we don’t have the right in this state to do that anymore, we have to be personally damaged God knows how many years after coming in contact with the harmful chemical, and then able to point the finger to the offending company, to be able to use the courts to do something about it. In other words, with 64, we’re unable to do anything about it until it’s already caused harm. The only workaround without revocation (and revocation will always be the ideal solution) is to hope heads of government agencies such as the CA EPA or energy and water commissions will use their authority to regulate and use the courts to protect the public.
5. All high-level government officials should be elected, not appointed, as much as possible. Direct democracy needs to include frequent voting on important issues at local, state, and national levels.
6. A set of socially-conscious mutual funds should be endorsed by the progressive community.
7. Micro-lending that has worked in many developing countries should be copied in the U.S.
8. Eliminate the cap on income subject to FICA/ social security taxation. By making there a cap, someone who makes 900 thousand pays the same FICA/ social security tax as someone who makes 90 thousand (the level at which the government stops taking out more for income-security programs). Make social security benefits more progressive.
9. As the Mercury itself editorialized recently, internet content providers and users should not be charged by phone or cable companies. They should not ever face a fee or slowing of information through telephone or cable infrastructure. This reform is called internet neutrality. Legislation is required to insure it applies and the internet remains a level playing field.
10. Maintain no tax on consumer purchases on internet sites for firms up to 100 employees. This may keep some firms inefficiently small, but the benefit of untaxed sales for the companies that qualify for the exemption and the revenue from major companies that must pay the sales tax combine for an extremely positive effect.
11. A benefits-received principle-based tax should be levied on oil companies to finance the military for securing and enhancing their supply points and prospects. Until we can influence the military not to deploy to vastly strengthen oil companies, those firms should chip in for this expensive (over $500 Billion this year) drain.
12. University construction, capacity, and budget should exceed prison construction, capacity, and budget even if that means decriminalizing nonviolent offenses. Some of these offenses are offensive to even be infractions.
Those are the reforms that flow for me from the concept of a Moral Economy. Tell me what you think and how we can make this happen.
I’m not the first to point out that progressives who are organizationally divided, compartmentalized by whatever issue they want to advocate, need to all gather activist strength to promote each others’ issues, even if it means overlooking peripheral disagreements with other progressive groups if it’s for progress on an issue most of us hold dear. As a hypothetical example, working women advocating equal pay to men or guaranteed maternity leave should be able to count on support from those advocating economic justice for the marginalized working class, and the women’s groups in turn support the marginalized worker, even if some members of the two groups may disagree as to whether hiring preferences should prioritize females or the historically underrepresented ethnicities.
While I want to focus on the moral economy, the flux which is the current status of our main local paper, the Mercury, highlights the increasingly vital role publications like De-Bug occupy as an informational source. Depending on the Mercury’s future owner, news quality and local coverage in particular could descend abysmally. Alternative news sources, which nationally have become essential to get what’s really going on, may become much more essential than mainstream news to figure what what’s really happening locally. Political and economic actors (in other words, people) can only be as educated in their actions as the sources of information, one of which is the media. Strengthening the web of local media in every way is key.
While our existence is much more than this, it is partly founded on the democratic (or dictatorial) nature of politics, media, and the economy. To that effect, I propose a set of reforms all progressive should back and use to inform any future debate on these issues. These reforms are a building block for others to contribute more ideas for bettering the existence of the vast majority of people in our local spheres and ultimately everywhere.
1. Promote multi-producer trading affiliations with barter-based exchange.
When people can get close to the same thing from someone in their community with the skill to provide that good or service, by all means figure out an adequate trade and save your money rather than depositing green into a consumer-creating machine with a distant profit center. Now if you’re sure the business is locally owned then it may be other story, but you still may want to consider the non-cash trade rather than a purchase.
2. Social enterprises are worker-owned, usually in the service- or capital-light industries. Depending on the people involved, the possibilities could be a restaurant or coffee shop, office or hotel cleaning service, clothes or soap-making, or something totally different which could be pursued, and programs to provide money, loans, or tax breaks to these organizations should be advocated.
3. CA Proposition 13 should exclude firms. Giving away all that lost property tax revenue to firms is not in keeping with the save the old people arguments for the proposition, and the argument business would leave is not strong since California offers all sorts of benefits that no other state has, and many qualities that are totally unmatched in the Western U.S. The concentration of existing businesses, the coast, Silicon Valley, Hollywood, the Universities all offer competitive advantages businesses will not ignore if they are forced to pay their share of property tax. The revenue should go into improving all levels of public education. This is the historically, though eroded of late, use of property tax revenue.
4. Revoke CA Proposition 64 to enable preemptive suits against harmful corporate output such as chemicals or pollution. To get rid of CA proposition 64 opens the door for watchdog groups to use the courts to stop firms from producing in ways that will likely damage humans or the environment. Yes, shockingly, we don’t have the right in this state to do that anymore, we have to be personally damaged God knows how many years after coming in contact with the harmful chemical, and then able to point the finger to the offending company, to be able to use the courts to do something about it. In other words, with 64, we’re unable to do anything about it until it’s already caused harm. The only workaround without revocation (and revocation will always be the ideal solution) is to hope heads of government agencies such as the CA EPA or energy and water commissions will use their authority to regulate and use the courts to protect the public.
5. All high-level government officials should be elected, not appointed, as much as possible. Direct democracy needs to include frequent voting on important issues at local, state, and national levels.
6. A set of socially-conscious mutual funds should be endorsed by the progressive community.
7. Micro-lending that has worked in many developing countries should be copied in the U.S.
8. Eliminate the cap on income subject to FICA/ social security taxation. By making there a cap, someone who makes 900 thousand pays the same FICA/ social security tax as someone who makes 90 thousand (the level at which the government stops taking out more for income-security programs). Make social security benefits more progressive.
9. As the Mercury itself editorialized recently, internet content providers and users should not be charged by phone or cable companies. They should not ever face a fee or slowing of information through telephone or cable infrastructure. This reform is called internet neutrality. Legislation is required to insure it applies and the internet remains a level playing field.
10. Maintain no tax on consumer purchases on internet sites for firms up to 100 employees. This may keep some firms inefficiently small, but the benefit of untaxed sales for the companies that qualify for the exemption and the revenue from major companies that must pay the sales tax combine for an extremely positive effect.
11. A benefits-received principle-based tax should be levied on oil companies to finance the military for securing and enhancing their supply points and prospects. Until we can influence the military not to deploy to vastly strengthen oil companies, those firms should chip in for this expensive (over $500 Billion this year) drain.
12. University construction, capacity, and budget should exceed prison construction, capacity, and budget even if that means decriminalizing nonviolent offenses. Some of these offenses are offensive to even be infractions.
Those are the reforms that flow for me from the concept of a Moral Economy. Tell me what you think and how we can make this happen.
Comments:
When I was in my college liberal mode back in the 60's, liberal meant caring about the rank & file poor folk. We students were not from poor famililies, but we lived frugally. Ie. we lived, dressed & ate like poor folk. We identified with poor folk. Poor folk have always been the vast majority & the backbone of every society. Healthy poor folk (not an oxymoron) meant a healthy backbone for society. Poor folk are also vulnerable: to exploitation, drugs, desperate acts & arrest. The poor never were popular. The poor were forgiving & understanding. Under the rubric of caring about the disadvantaged, spawned other, much smaller, but virulent special interest groups. Soon clamoring for relief with mainstream poor were: abortionists, traditional gays, weirdo gays, illegal aliens, drug addicts, sex addicts, NAMBLA, radical environmentalists, Blacks, Black Muslims, animal rights advocates, animal sodomists, polygamists, etc.
This is not to vilify these groups. They have a need & a right to exist. We as a society have a need for them to be here. They expand our consciousness and are vital members of our society. But, the liberalism which I knew 40 years ago meant feed & care for the poor. No doubt that theme still exists, but it got lost in the multitude of the bizarre and fascinating bedfellows clambering for the microphone. Until liberals return to their cause celebre: promoting the needs of the poor instead of diverting their energy into marriage licenses for gays, they are destined to be impotent. The monied right wing will gladly let the poor languish in desperation while tossing the liberals a few cheap bones like: gay marriage licenses; abortion rights; medical marajuana; etc.
This is not to vilify these groups. They have a need & a right to exist. We as a society have a need for them to be here. They expand our consciousness and are vital members of our society. But, the liberalism which I knew 40 years ago meant feed & care for the poor. No doubt that theme still exists, but it got lost in the multitude of the bizarre and fascinating bedfellows clambering for the microphone. Until liberals return to their cause celebre: promoting the needs of the poor instead of diverting their energy into marriage licenses for gays, they are destined to be impotent. The monied right wing will gladly let the poor languish in desperation while tossing the liberals a few cheap bones like: gay marriage licenses; abortion rights; medical marajuana; etc.
It is interesting to note that the guidelines for a moral economy, which you have laid out, adress the need to, essentially, tax business more, and generally to promote a shift away from astronomical profit. But I would provoke the following idea: What if profits were merely directed to the social cause. In this case business profit would be synonomous with expansion of social programs. Because the various programs could be promoted by private funds, they would not have to be sifted through the beaurocatic congressional complex. Funds could be disseminated more quickly, and with greater affect.
For example, Bill Gates personally has funds on the order of, say, 30B. What if he WILLFULLY AND WILLINGLY donated 15B (or dare I say 29B) to social causes. Lets say it costs 1K to dig a well in Africa. Do the math.
How can it be acceptable in the consciousness of rich people and corporations, to do no good acts with these incredible funds. If business directed profit to the people for the sake of doing good, a "moral economy" could exist hand in hand with laze-faire regulation.
Furthermore a change in moral conciousness- ethical standards- negates the ever present loophole jumping propensity that capitalism encourages. One may question even the practical possiblity that a "moral economy," even with explicit guidlines could be enforced. Even with anti-trust laws, monopolies retain power by being convicted and paying nominal fines (e.g. De Beers 2004). Corporate criminals serve little to no time, and often are not even prosecuted.
A moral economy, yes. But the "moral" needs to come from the actors, the businesspeople, the money. If profit were funneled to those who need it, we may start liking capitalism after all.
Post a Comment
For example, Bill Gates personally has funds on the order of, say, 30B. What if he WILLFULLY AND WILLINGLY donated 15B (or dare I say 29B) to social causes. Lets say it costs 1K to dig a well in Africa. Do the math.
How can it be acceptable in the consciousness of rich people and corporations, to do no good acts with these incredible funds. If business directed profit to the people for the sake of doing good, a "moral economy" could exist hand in hand with laze-faire regulation.
Furthermore a change in moral conciousness- ethical standards- negates the ever present loophole jumping propensity that capitalism encourages. One may question even the practical possiblity that a "moral economy," even with explicit guidlines could be enforced. Even with anti-trust laws, monopolies retain power by being convicted and paying nominal fines (e.g. De Beers 2004). Corporate criminals serve little to no time, and often are not even prosecuted.
A moral economy, yes. But the "moral" needs to come from the actors, the businesspeople, the money. If profit were funneled to those who need it, we may start liking capitalism after all.

